While EcoVadis doesn’t technically use the term “fail” for their sustainability assessment, receiving a low score can feel remarkably similar to failing when it affects your business relationships and opportunities. The assessment uses a 0-100 scoring system, and whilst there’s no official pass/fail threshold, scores below certain levels can lead to supply chain exclusion and missed partnerships. Understanding what constitutes concerning performance and how to improve disappointing ratings is crucial for maintaining competitive advantage.
What does it actually mean to ‘fail’ an EcoVadis assessment?
EcoVadis operates on a 0-100 point scoring system rather than a traditional pass/fail structure, but practically speaking, low scores can have consequences that feel very much like failing. The assessment evaluates companies across four sustainability themes using seven key management indicators, with scores awarded in increments of 25 (0, 25, 50, 75, 100) for each indicator.
Understanding what constitutes a concerning EcoVadis score requires examining several key benchmarks:
- Industry thresholds: Large corporations typically set minimum supplier requirements ranging from 25-45 points, depending on sector risk profiles and sustainability expectations
- Universal red flags: Scores below 25 points indicate minimal sustainability management systems across all industries and often trigger immediate supplier reviews
- Medal benchmarks: Companies scoring below 45 points receive no medal recognition, signaling to stakeholders that performance needs significant improvement
- Competitive positioning: Bronze medal scores (45-62 points) represent the top 35% of assessed companies, making sub-45 scores competitively disadvantageous
These benchmarks collectively demonstrate that whilst EcoVadis doesn’t officially define failure, market expectations and business consequences create practical thresholds that companies must meet. The medal system particularly influences stakeholder perceptions, as medal-less scores often signal inadequate sustainability management to potential partners and customers.
What happens when your EcoVadis score is lower than expected?
Low EcoVadis scores can trigger several immediate business consequences that extend far beyond disappointing internal teams. Supply chain exclusion represents the most direct impact, as many multinational corporations now require minimum EcoVadis ratings from their suppliers and partners.
The business impacts of disappointing EcoVadis scores manifest across multiple areas:
- Supply chain exclusion: Multinational corporations increasingly mandate minimum EcoVadis scores for supplier qualification, with scores below thresholds resulting in automatic disqualification from procurement processes
- Customer relationship deterioration: B2B clients factor sustainability ratings into vendor selection, particularly in manufacturing, retail, and technology sectors where supply chain responsibility drives competitive advantage
- Tender disadvantages: Companies with higher ratings consistently win contracts over competitors with similar offerings but lower sustainability scores, as corporate buyers face pressure to demonstrate responsible procurement
- Partnership limitations: Strategic alliances and joint ventures increasingly require aligned sustainability credentials, limiting collaboration opportunities for poorly-rated companies
- Investor scrutiny: ESG-focused investors and lenders examine third-party sustainability ratings when making funding decisions, potentially affecting capital access and terms
These consequences compound over time, creating a sustainability performance gap that becomes increasingly difficult to overcome as market expectations continue rising. Different industries maintain varying threshold expectations, with automotive typically demanding higher scores due to complex supply chains, whilst service industries may accept lower initial scores with improvement commitments.
How can you improve a disappointing EcoVadis rating?
Improving your EcoVadis rating requires a systematic approach that addresses the assessment’s four core themes: Environment, Labour and Human Rights, Ethics, and Sustainable Procurement. The key lies in understanding that EcoVadis evaluates both policy development and practical implementation across 21 specific indicators.
Effective EcoVadis improvement strategies focus on several critical areas:
- Policy framework development: Create comprehensive, documented policies aligned with international standards like the Global Reporting Initiative and UN Global Compact, ensuring coverage across all four assessment themes
- Implementation evidence: Establish monitoring systems, accountability structures, and performance metrics that demonstrate genuine management system integration rather than superficial policy statements
- Documentation quality: Prepare clear, dated, official documents including training records, audit reports, supplier assessments, and performance data that EcoVadis analysts can easily verify
- Supply chain engagement: Develop supplier sustainability programs with assessment processes, improvement requirements, and monitoring systems that demonstrate sustainable procurement management
- Continuous monitoring: Implement ongoing measurement and reporting systems that track progress against sustainability objectives and provide evidence of systematic improvement
These improvement efforts work synergistically to create a comprehensive sustainability management system that satisfies EcoVadis methodology requirements. Working with specialised sustainability consultants can accelerate progress by identifying specific gaps and aligning efforts with assessment criteria, particularly when internal teams lack experience with the platform’s unique requirements.
When should you seek expert help with your EcoVadis assessment?
Professional assistance becomes valuable when your internal team lacks experience with EcoVadis methodology or when previous assessment attempts resulted in unexpectedly low scores. The assessment’s comprehensive nature, covering 21 indicators across multiple sustainability themes, often requires specialised knowledge to navigate effectively.
Several scenarios indicate that expert guidance would provide significant value:
- First-time assessments: Companies new to EcoVadis benefit from specialists who understand specific documentation requirements and scoring methodologies that differ from other sustainability frameworks
- Disappointing previous scores: When internal efforts haven’t translated into expected ratings, experts can identify gaps between genuine sustainability efforts and EcoVadis presentation requirements
- Tight deadlines: Time-constrained situations require focused expertise to prioritise high-impact improvements and avoid common preparation pitfalls that delay submission
- Resource constraints: Limited internal sustainability expertise makes external specialists cost-effective for accessing concentrated knowledge without long-term hiring commitments
- Industry-specific requirements: Sectors with unique sustainability challenges benefit from consultants experienced in relevant regulatory frameworks and stakeholder expectations
These situations highlight how specialised EcoVadis consultants differ significantly from general sustainability advisors, focusing specifically on evidence-based assessment preparation rather than broader strategic planning. The strategic value extends beyond initial completion, as experienced consultants establish systems supporting continuous improvement and annual reassessment success.
Getting your EcoVadis assessment right
Understanding that you can’t technically “fail” an EcoVadis assessment shouldn’t diminish the importance of achieving a strong score. The practical implications of low ratings on business relationships and competitive positioning make thorough preparation essential.
Whether you’re facing your initial assessment or working to improve a disappointing score, the complexity of the process often benefits from expert guidance. At Dazzle, we connect you with pre-screened sustainability consultants who specialise in EcoVadis assessments. Our flexible approach means you can access the right expertise within 48 hours, whether you need project-based support or ongoing guidance. Ready to transform your sustainability efforts into a globally recognised certification? Reach out to our team of experts today.
Related Articles
- What is the difference between hiring interim sustainability managers vs permanent employees?
- What skills should you look for when hiring sustainability consultants in 2025?
- Is EcoVadis mandatory for suppliers?
- What documents do you need for an EcoVadis assessment?
- What happens during an EcoVadis assessment?
